Showing posts with label modernising the curriculum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label modernising the curriculum. Show all posts

Wednesday, 26 August 2015

Numbers taking GCSE D&T continue to decline - why?

Why has the number of teenagers taking design and technology GCSE dropped?

Alison Hardy, Nottingham Trent University

There has been a worrying decline in recent years in the number of teenagers opting to take design and technology (D&T) at GCSE. While the results of exams in maths, English and science lead the headlines, other, more practical subjects rarely get a mention – even though they are falling towards a crisis.

D&T GCSE entries are down yet again this year. Since 2000, when D&T stopped being a compulsory GCSE subject, there has been a steady decline in the number of pupils achieving a GCSE in the subject.

Once D&T was the most popular optional subject at GCSE, now it is less popular than religious studies, history and geography and with the ascendancy of computing and art and design (which is separate from D&T). Who knows where it might be in 2016?

Some D&T teachers have argued that entry numbers are falling because of the focus on the Ebacc – a performance measure that requires students to take five core GCSE subjects including maths and a science.

But that doesn’t stack up. The downward trend has been happening for more than ten years and other non-Ebacc subjects have not suffered a decline. This year religious studies has nearly 300,000 entries, its highest level since 2002 and music was up by 2.2% to nearly 50,000.

Another possible explanation is how well pupils do in D&T. Diana Choulerton, lead inspector for the subject, reported that typically higher ability pupils make less progress in D&T than most other subjects. As schools are now measured on a pupils' progress in eight subjects, there is a pressure on school leaders to guide pupils to choose GCSE subjects where they will do well – and avoid D&T.

Not just cushion covers and bird boxes

One of the problems it that D&T has an image problem. Is it a practical subject, teaching life skills? A vocational subject? Or is it an academic subject?

It only became known as D&T in 1990 with the introduction of the National Curriculum. Before then it comprised several subjects including cooking, dressmaking, technical drawing, woodwork and metalwork, where children made bird boxes, cushion covers and scones. However, some schools made strides to change this by teaching home economics and craft, design and technology.

My recent research shows there continues to be significant confusion as to the purpose of the subject. Today many parents and adults still see D&T as this practical life-skills subject, and in some schools children are making the same things their parents made at school.

Parents see it as a non-academic subject that doesn’t belong alongside subjects such as science, history, and languages. And this is one the biggest challenges facing D&T: in some schools it hasn’t evolved into a modern subject, fit for the 21st century.

I wrote this article earlier in the week for The Conversation. It only summarises a few of the reasons why the numbers have dropped - it is complex but I think these are the headlines - what do you think?

Does D&T matter?

Both the Royal Academy of Engineers and the Design Council consider D&T to be a vital subject for growth in their industries. The need for those with science, technology, engineering and maths qualifications is regularly in the news and high on the government’s agenda. Companies such as the James Dyson Foundation are trying to influence what is taught in D&T lessons.

Yet the current GCSE is still a disjointed subject made up of different GCSE strands which are described by the materials the pupils use in the lessons: such as food technology, textiles technology, electronic products or resistant materials.

But from 2017, there will be a new D&T GCSE taught in schools. In this reformed “single title” GCSE – which won’t be split up into the different strands – pupils will learn how to use a broader range of materials than they do currently, where they primarily use only their one chosen category of material, such as textiles.

There will also be a brand new food preparation and nutrition GCSE, taught as a life-skill and preparation for a career in the food industry. D&T will be a qualification that provides children with an understanding about how they can bring about change in the world through good design. It will also be an essential qualification for careers and work-related skills, not just life skills.

However, the reduction in school budgets could scupper this attempt to solve the subject’s image problem. D&T is an expensive subject, and the materials, machines and equipment schools need are comparable in cost to science subjects. For a headteacher who is between a rock (league tables) and a hard place (reduced budgets), D&T is an easy target for cuts.

In this context, D&T teachers need to radically rethink what they teach. The new GCSE means that children could be designing products that address modern issues related to health, developing communities and protecting people, using robotics and smart materials. A challenge – but D&T teachers are creative. Hopefully this means we will see an end to the bird box and cushion cover.

David Barlex, educational consultant, and director for design and technology at the Nuffield Foundation, provided advice for this article.

Alison Hardy is Lecturer in Design and Technology Education at Nottingham Trent University

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Wednesday, 14 January 2015

What is 3D printed textiles?

Laura Cooper, a second year student on the BSc (Hons) Secondary D&T Education, gave a excellent presentation on Monday afternoon about 3D textiles that has received little mention in D&T. Below is a brief synopsis of her talk using images, videos and links she shared with the audience.
Laura's presentation is part of a series led by our students and visitors are welcome to attend. Details of the next two can be found at the end of this post.

Defining 3D printed textiles

3 D printing involves 2D layering a material, usually a plastic, to create a 3D shape. This can be done using a 3D printer where the layers are created using a nozzle that ejects the plastic or selective laser sintering (Figure 1) where layers of powder are fused together with a laser (this is a form of rapid prototyping). These processes allows for complex shapes to be manufactured that are already interlinked rather than individual pieces being made and joining afterwards – a form of chain mail.

Figure 1: interlocking sections designed by Bradley Rothenburg

3D printing with textiles also removes the need for seams and by using a body scanner it has the potential to produce clothing items which fit your body perfectly - assuming this is what we want!

Figure 2: the process of selective laser printing

What’s happening now with 3D printing? The current position

In 2013 the fashion designer Iris van Herpen and architect Professor Neri Oxman designed a cat walk 3D printed item (Figure 3) which demonstrated the versatility of intricate shapes that can be designed using a 3D printer.

Figure 3:Cat walk design by Iris van Herpen and Professor Neri Oxman

One of the properties most important in designing garments is the fluidity and flexibility of the materials; some designers from Nervous System have begun to resolve the problems with 3D printers producing very rigid materials by looking at how things can be interlinked.

Another restriction with traditionally produced 3D products is that their size is limited by the printer bed's dimensions. Nervous System resolved this by using a physics computer modelling to have the garment made as a 'crumpled' dress rather than the more traditional idea of being cut out flat (figure 4).

Figure 4: maximising the size of the printer bed

This does begin to push the scope of what is a textile, given that currently most of the designs seem to be made using a plastic but in a more rigid form than might be commonly seen in fashion design.

How might it be in the future?

Joshua Harris has begun to think of a future scenario where we all might have a 3D printer in our home; Barlex and Stevens (2012) have also considered this as a disruptive technology. In this situation with one in our home he imagines the process could be this;
1.  Select clothing designs from a catalogue and purchase the design drawing file, which is sent to you for downloading.
2.  Buy cartridges to print out your clothes using cotton.
3.  Have your body scanned to capture your individual measurements.
4.  Before going to bed select your outfit for the next day, overnight the printer makes your clothes (Figure 5).

Figure 5: Choosing your outfit (step 4)
5.  Next morning you leave the house in your ‘new’ clothes that fit you perfectly
6.  Come home and if you don’t want to wear them again, shred and recycle the cotton ready for making new clothes tomorrow.

What might be some implications of this 'disruptive technology'?

These are some question posed by Laura in the session that are a good starting point for discussion in D&T lessons.

•      If designers are selling the designs and cartridges, what happens to our high street stores? Jobs lost?
•      From own experience I don’t buy clothes to fit exact. Buy larger clothes to change the style of an outfit. Does entering our measurements hinder the individuality of a person?
•      What about the option of buying clothes as a gift for someone's birthday? Would we have to carry around a book of measurements of close family and friends on the off chance we want to surprise them with a garment for their birthday?
•      If you’ve paid for the design will this always be available to you? If so will the consumers build up a catalogue of garments and never need to purchase a design again?

Further into the future

Scientists have begun to investigate how silk worms ‘3D print’ silk fabric with the idea of mimicking this in the design of a new 3D textile printer – biomimicry in action (see video below).




Finally - The next stage of Laura's work is to suggest how this topic can be used within a series of D&T lessons, with the hope that she might be able to use some when on school placement next year.

Next presentations:
Monday 19th January - Cultured meat
Monday 26th January - Biomimicry
Both start at 4pm in Maudslay 222, City Campus, Nottingham Trent University, NG1 4BU

If you would like to attend or want some further information please drop me an email: alison.hardy@ntu.ac.uk

Reference
Barlex, D. & Stevens, M. (2012 Making by printing – disruption inside and outside school? in Thomas Ginner, Jonas Helstrom and Magnus Hulten (Eds) Technology Education in the 21st Century Proceedings of the PATT 26 Conference 2012, 64 – 73, Stockholm, Linkoping University  available here

Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Food security: a topic for design and technology

At the beginning of the term my colleague, Beverley Lawe,  led a seminar for year 2 about ‘Food Security’, part of the module Design and Technology in Education and Society; today I followed this up by exploring with the students this topic's potential use in D&T. In this post I’m sharing some of our discussion, beginning with a summary of the topic and then presenting three possible activities in which food security could be used as a starting point. These activities use the NTU D&T curriculum model as a framework.

World diet
As the world population’s diet changes to reflect the perceived affluent diet of western countries, which includes meat as a staple element, there is a greater demand on arable land to produce food for the animals rather than for people to eat. The land needed to feed an animal which will be slaughtered is greater than the land needed to feed a person from vegetation (fruit, veg, wheat etc). Therefore we need to make some changes.
These changes could include:
  • people eating less meat (Meat free Mondays campaign is an example of this)
  • cultured meat (not meat but a simulation created in a test tube)
Power of the supermarkets
We had some debate as to whether it was the supermarkets driving this, or the consumer but this is the basic premise of our argument:

We focussed on the decreasing variety of different food products available (Aldi and Lidl are masters of this), for example: do you need a ‘finest’, ‘essentials’, and the branded versions of cream crackers? By restricting the choice they make the shopping experience simpler (no more dithering in the aisle) but there are consequences:
  1. We come to expect the same ‘type’ of pasta/apple/cracker throughout the year, which forces the supermarkets to source some of these from overseas. This particularly affects fresh fruit and veg being imported and means we tend not to buy seasonal or local.
  2. We become accustomed to a particular taste and always buy the same ones; the apple is an example of this. Golden Delicious apples have dominated the market for a while, they are easy to produce with a consistent smell, taste and appearance; consequently there is now an impoverished choice of apples on the supermarket shelves. Work by Hogg (see Kierl 2014, p.80) in 1875 recorded 475 varieties of apples.
I’m not claiming to have all of my facts correct here but I think I’ve captured the essence of what the students have remembered from Beverley’s seminar.

My question to year 2 was: How can this topic be relevant for D&T? We discussed this today and I proposed the following ideas using the NTU D&T curriculum model as a framework.

Mainly designing
A conceptual approach could be taken with the world diet; ask pupils in groups to use data about the increasing world population, its wealth and change in diet (I’m sure geography teachers could help out here). Ask some pertinent ‘What if..?’ questions to try and think about the future.  
From here pupils could identify some positive and negative consequences about the increased demand for meat. You could begin to explore these situations with them:
  • How could we increase the amount of land for growing vegetation to feed people (or animals)?
  • Why do people want to eat meat? What’s the alternative?
  • How could we encourage people on a large scale to change their eating habits? I’ve deliberately suggested large scale as the idea isn’t in this activity to design and make a food product, instead maybe a campaign or programme.
Mainly making
This activity could start with familiarising pupils with the alternatives to meat, some already available (e.g. tofu and quorn), some in development (e.g. cultured meat) or just no-meat food products. To start with pupils could blind taste test food products that do not include any meat product, in groups with focussed questions.
The next stage could be to give groups a non-meat alternative to test and experiment with, e.g. boiling, frying, roasting, raw etc. This is an investigative part of making that is very successful with food.
Finally pupils could be asked to modify an existing recipe that contains meat, removing the meat component and replacing it with a alternative but not compromising on taste or appearance.
In this activity the design decisions pupils make are technical, constructional and aesthetic, they are not being asked to consider the market or the concept; this in my opinion is what makes it a ‘mainly making’ activity.

Designing and making
Starting with the power of the supermarkets as a concept and the ‘impoverished choice’ of different varieties of fruit and veg on the supermarket shelves (e.g. carrots or apples), pupils could design a marketing campaign for a local food supplier that specialises in a particular fruit or veg or a local speciality. This is obviously a seasonal brief, with different food produce being used dependent on locality.

All of these have a central component of Design and Technology in Society, the fourth component of NTU's curriculum model, allowing pupils to explore the consequences and possible solutions to this local, national and international food dilemma.

To many D&T teachers these activities are nothing new, but to some of our undergraduate trainee teachers they are, and a main aim of the module is to challenge them to think about how topics, such as food security, can be used in D&T lessons.

If you want to know more about food security Beverley asked year 2 to listen to a podcast from the BBC Radio 4 Food Programme.

If you want to know more about the NTU D&T curriculum model read the paper I presented with David Barlex in New Zealand last year, pages 214-218.

Reference
Kierl, S., 2014. Ethical Technological Literacy. In: J.R.Dakers, ed. Defining Technological Literacy. Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.