Thursday, 18 September 2014

What's in a name? or where's the 'and' in design technology?


Earlier in the week I took to Twitter to ask the provocative question: What is our subject called? This followed an innocent comment on a blog where design and technology was called ‘Design Technology’ and a journalist in the Guardian talking about their experiences in design technology. Both irritated me and by Monday afternoon I couldn’t keep my irritation to myself; but why should it irritate me? I want to cover two points in this post to help answer that question: firstly an explanation of the subject title, and secondly why getting it right is important.

At the inception of the National Curriculum, prior to 1990 (Wakefield and Owen-Jackson 2013), a working party defined the subject (DES1988) and called it design and technololgy.  So there it is: design AND technology. I could end there but its useful to consider why the ‘and’, why ‘design’ not just ‘technology’ and vice versa.

The ‘and’ exists for a purpose. As Tristram Shepard pointed out in a tweet  ‘design technology’ as a noun does not exist, but there is ‘design’ and there is ‘technology’; The ‘and’ brings together two existing nouns, ‘design’ and ‘technology’, as a compound noun and therefore a ‘unitary concept’ (DES1988, p.2). The explanation in the working in the report is so clear I will repeat it here:
‘…most, but not all, design activities will generally include technology and most technology activities will include design… our use of design and technology a unitary concept, to be spoken in one breath as it were, does not therefore embody redundancy. It is intended to emphasis the intimate connection between the two activities as well as to imply a concept, which is broader than either design or technology individual, and the whole of which we believe is educationally important. (Accordingly we use design and technology a compound noun taking the singular form of verbs…) (p.2)

It is not two parts ‘design’ and ‘technology’ as was suggested in the first, and atrocious, rewrite of the new National Curriculum (Department of Education 2013). For the sake of repetition to highlight the importance: it is a unitary concept represented as a compound noun ‘to be spoken in one breath’ (1988, p.2).

This name does have implications for the curriculum delivery, content and epistemology, which lead to my second point: the importance of getting the name right.

Wakefield and Owen-Jackson (2013) remind us that for a brief period design and technology was a subsidiary of a subject called technology; this included business studies and IT. The consequence here was a combination of mismatched subjects, with different types of knowledge and purposes. As a comparison in other countries the subject is called technology or a subsidiary of faculty of subjects (see Dugger Jr 2009, and Ginestié 2009). These scenarios come from or result in different approaches and purposes to (design and) technology* education (de Vries 2012). I think Ginestie (2009) thinks this arises from the ‘lack of clarity of a defined epistemology for (design and) technology*, which is the argument the Expert Panel (Design and Technology Association 2011) for removing D&T as a foundation subject. I am not going to explore the epistemology of our subject here that is for another blog post (once I have delved into work by Kurt Seeman).

I’ve touched on the name change but now I want to question the impact of the changing name. What was design and technology called when you were at school? My history in D&T is this:
·      Primary school: nothing
·      Secondary school:
o   First year (1981): woodwork, metalwork, domestic science, sewing, drawing, painting and pottery;
o   Second and third year (1982-84): all of the above, except woodwork and metalwork;
o   Fourth and fifth years (1984-86): O level Graphical Communication
o   A level (1986-88): Design, Craft and Technology (DCT)

D&T’s history is important; Martin (2013) proposes five design and technology eras. My ideas about these five eras, name/s related to the subject and the approximate years they took place in:

  • Era of making: Students in this period studied subjects such as craft, technical drawing and sewing between 1970 and 1986.
  • Era of personalizing: this was between 1985 & 1990; a very short period and I relate it to my own experiences when I did DCT (the Welsh version of CDT);
  •  Era of designing; during the first iteration of the National Curriculum between 1990 & 1996 with the focus from the four attainment targets ((Wakefield and Owen-Jackson 2013).
  • Era of manufacturing; 1995 to 2005 linked to the instigation and implementation of Tomlinson’s report (2004) resulting in Diplomas and GCSEs including Engineering and Manufacturing.
  • Era of valuing; 2000 to 2007 saw a greater focus in the whole National Curriculum on values, ethics and citizenship. No changes to the subject name were made but there was a shift in emphasis, which I think led to the ‘Importance Statements’ (2007).

My history in being a student of D&T straddles the eras of making and personalizing, and this probably had an effect on my naming and teaching of the subject. Consequently I probably projected an incorrect image of design and technology to my peers and stakeholders of the subject.

To summarise the name is the subject’s identity, calling it by any other name implies a different subject. The purpose and focus of design and technology is all in its name; call it by another name and it becomes a different subject with a different purpose.

I would welcome your thoughts on the name, how a name defines a subject and any other thoughts you have regarding the comments I have made here.

References

De Vries, M., 2012. Philosophy of Technology.  In: P.J. Williams, ed.,   Technology Education for Teachers. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers, 2012, pp. 15-33.
Department of Education, 2013.  The National Curriculum in England Framework document (February 2013). London: Department of Education.
Design and Technology Association, 2011.  Report by the Expert Panel for the National Curriculum review (DfE, December 2011) [online]. Design and Technology Association. Available at: http://bit.ly/14GHAZv [Accessed July 24 2013].
Dugger Jr, W.E., 2009. Developments in technology education in the United States of America. International Handbook of Research and Development in Technology Education, , 65-84.
Ginestié, J., 2009. Thinking about technology education in France. International Handbook of Research and Development in Technology Education, , 31-40.
Great Britain. Department for Education and Science and the Welsh Office, 1988.  
National Curriculum Design and Technology Working Group Interim Report.
London: DES.

Great Britain. Department for Education and Skills, 2004.  Final Report of the Working Group on 14-19 Reform. Nottingham: DfES.
Martin, M., 2013. Five Eras of Making and Designing.  In: PATT27 Technology Education for the Future: A Play on Sustainability, Chirstchurch, New Zealand, 2-6 December 2013. pp. 318-324.
Qualifications and Curriculum Authority, 2007.  The National Curriculum : statutory requirements for key stages 3 and 4. London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
Wakefield, D., and Owen-Jackson, G., 2013. Government policies and design and technology education. Debates in Design and Technology Education, , 7.




*I would prefer to write design and technology here but the authors refer to technology education in their writing.

With thanks to David Barlex for pointing me in the direction of the Parkes report, and Tristram Shepard, Jo Hayes and Matt McLain for their views on the name, which helped clarify my thinking.

Monday, 19 May 2014

DfE discussion about CPD

I've just picked up this hashtag (#dfecpd) on Twitter today and I'm wondering what D&T teachers CPD needs are:


  • Did you need more support in your NQT year about subject pedagogy?
  • Are their problems with location and access to CPD?
  • Is technology the answer to accessing CPD?
  • How can local ITT, Teaching Schools and universities, providers help?
  • What impact are TeachMeets having on your subject pedagogy?
I'm interested to hear your thoughts.



To find out about CPD at NTU's Centre for Design and Technology visit our blog.

Wednesday, 5 March 2014

Top 10 hints for part time PhD students

Another new role - Graduate School student rep for the School of Education at NTU. This means I now have a voice at the university as a student as well as a member of staff (I just like to talk!). As part of this I've met a new part time education PhD student at NTU (Welcome Jim!) to share some of the highs and lows of being part time. Whilst talking I realised that I was listing a top ten of hints for part time study so thought I'd share them here in two shorter lists:

Technology:
  1. Use evernote: I find it hard to justify spending money on apps and subscriptions but this one is worth every penny. The best bits: As I type a new note into Evernote it finds related notes - a godsend for me as I only have a bit of time on the bus to write and I can't carry all those notebooks with me. 
  2. Get a twitter acount: its fun, its a distraction and then there's hastags..... Particulalry #phdchat and #ptphd (I think there is only me using this one)
  3. Read PhD blogs: and not just by current PhD students but also those written by supervisors.
  4. Use an online referencing site. At NTU Refworks is available and I'm quite happy with it. Why: anything I find via Google Scholar in my five minutes of time I put straight into Refworks ready for me to go back to, to cite and to use - a time saver.
  5. Join an online group which helps you and you can give back to. I started the DTE google group after PATT27 in Christchurch. There were 12 or so phd students at the conference whose thesis focusses on technology education with no online meeting place - so I set one up, which links to point 3 below.
Practicalities/social:
  1. Read the university regulations and plan for key dates: I took a while to realise that this is part of my PhD study; understanding the regulations and expectations are important.
  2. Writing: 1. Do some everyday (or so): there's lots out there about writing everyday (Elbow, Goodson etc) but you do need to find out what fits you. Talking to Helen Sword last December I realised I was becoming a slave to the 'everyday' expectation (I have enough hair shirts in my wardrobe without adding another). 2. Read about writing: this is my thing at the moment. I've got to be careful it doesn't distract me from actually writing but I know I need to improve the style of my writing. Poor writing detracts from content - if I'm spending all this time doing good quality, well thought through research, which I hope is ground breaking, I want it to be readable.
  3. Meet up with other PT PhD students: whether online or face to face. This has helped me enormously, I don't feel so alone.
  4. Don't despair: you're part time, it's a marathon not a sprint. There will be periods when you don't get much done, which leads me onto my next point....
  5. Thinking about your literature, muling over your data collection, jotting notes, spending 10 minutes here and there - these all count as your PhD time.

Thursday, 14 November 2013

Learning outcomes or learning objectives?

Distinguishing between a learning outcome, a learning objective and an activity is something many trainee teachers find challenging, along with how to write a good learning objective. It takes practice, and with 20 years in teaching I still take my time to write good learning objectives. So I wasn't surprised to receive this email from a student (I've slightly altered it and removed the student's name to protect her and the school). 

This post links to my article in the next Teach Design magazine.
Hi Alison, 
I am still having difficulty writing learning objectives, without it being an activity. What I find more confusing is, when I am looking in books to try and help me, many of their examples are what I would class as an activity.  
For example, 'Pupils will be able to select and safely use appropriate equipment'. Is that not an activity? 
I have taken over a Year 8 class that are in the process of making a cushion, so every lesson is a practical lesson. These are the lessons I am particularly struggling to write learning objectives for. On the odd occasion I am demonstrating how to apply bondaweb or appliqué, so when it comes to writing the objectives, I am ok with this. But the majority of the time they are applying previous knowledge to make their cushion. 
Any help would really be appreciated. 
Many thanks, 
PGCE student


Dear student,



This is quite a long response but I hope it helps. I've quoted some parts of your email so you can see my response.

'Pupils will be able to select and safely use appropriate equipment'. - I would say this is an outcome, they will be able to do this at the end of the lesson. 

'Every lesson is a practical lesson' - always a tricky one this but I think its useful for you to remember that the cushion cover is an application of their related learning about joining, combining, finishing. The cushion cover is a product to facilitate learning not the main purpose of the D&T lesson.

Developing their skills is where I would focus on the learning in these lessons. So some learning objectives might be:
  • learn how to assemble textile products using hand and machine techniques
  • learn a range of joining techniques and how to use them consistently and with precision
  • investigate and develop their skills in basic surface decoration
  • apply their knowledge of textiles equipment 
  • priortise their decisions about time and production order
By making a cushion cover they learn to make judgements and decisions about how and why they are using certain techniques rather than others in textiles, e.g why use a 2.5mm stitch length on a finished product rather than a 5mm?  Another example is they not only have to know how to make sure the seams are straights/curved/ accurate by using the markers on the guide plate they have to know why they are using it and why this accuracy is important. Learning objectives for these might be:
  • learn how to use a sewing machine to accurately and appropriately join fabric
Fitness for purpose is another learning activity when making a cushion cover. To be able to decide something is fit for purpose pupils need to understand the criteria used to make this judgement, e.g. withstand the agitation in the washing machine, .... (I'm not a textiles expert so flounder here a bit). You may need to spend sometime in the lesson developing this criteria which might already exist in their specification. If you plan some learning activities about creating fitness for purpose criteria for a cushion cover they can then use this to make judgements; therefore the learning criteria for these lessons could be:
  • analyse the work of others to develop fitness for purpose criteria
  • understand the criteria used to judge the fitness for purpose of a seam/ joining technique and/or decoration technique
  • apply their knowledge of [a particular] fabric/ decoration technique to make a product which is fit for purpose
I hope this helps,

Alison

PS I've used a lot of existing resources, including the SoW written by Sarah and me, to help me write these objectives. In other words - there's nothing wrong with using the work of others to give you sentence starters.




Monday, 16 September 2013

A typical D&T room - is that possible?



and many thanks to those of you who replied (see below for contributors).
So what did I find out?
Mainly that there’s a lot of ‘stuff’ in D&T rooms:
  • 3 x big old desks, band saw, scroll saws x 8, disc sander, jewellery trolleys, pillar drill, projector w. Apple TV, sink
  • 2 x lathe, milling machine, forge, pewter casting, 4 x old desks, pillar drill, band saw, projector
  • PCs on mezzanine + library, laser cutter, 3D printer, 5 x scroll saws, band saw, open plan desks, pillar drill, lathe, belt sand, Mobile whiteboard with projector + Apple TV, wall of whiteboards
  • 4 x open desks,18 x PCs, hand tools, laser & vinyl cutter, mobile white board + Apple TV + projector, sink, conf. table. Storage
  • Big screen. PCs. Technician. Lots of power sockets and space near by
  • Benches, stools and a timeline of machines & equipment with work crammed into any space available.
  • 11 double bench, ABC of DT, Keywords,3D letters-more coming soon
  • benching with vices for woods, metals, plastics. Organised tool boards, 2-3centre lathes, wood lathe, laser cutter, graphics equipment
  • One half woodwork benches and power tools, one half tables for 'designing'. Lots of safety notices. Lack of storage space
  • HDPE plastic collecting, machines, tool stations, spray booth- off cut box
  • metal/wood work benches, wood and metal lathes, tool cupboard, sander, pillar drill, laser cutter
  • 'hand tools/machines/laser cutter/work benches/wood & metal vices/
  • projector & whiteboard/laptops/display-exemplar work, levels & keywords'
  • student work of the week, articles, icons, ukdesigners, Old layout, new kit, dash of tech

But what’s missing from this list? There’s no mention of textiles technology, food technology and little related to systems & control. I’d really like to hear from D&T teachers who use these materials so I can add the detail to my research.
Hidden in these tweets were pedagogic ideas and the teacher’s personality:
  • mobile whiteboards, good reads, stories of past students, inspiration, quotes
  • create ideas with out designing
  • student work of the week
  • 1 big group table to share ideas
  • #accessFM#cafeque posters
  • ABC of DT – would be great if @patlink could share this
I loved this one:
  • @hardy_alison workbenches that subliminally trick students into thinking that the room is only for making! Old layout, new kit, dash of tech

It revealed to me the dichotomy that exists sometimes in D&T: do we make or design? And what do pupils prefer? (A blog post for another time).
And then things that made me sit up and smile about the uniqueness of D&T and its teachers:
  • teachers' current projects
  • technology, lots of it.
  • versatile, organised, enabling, inspirational, airy, robust, technological, evocative smelling, noisy, serious, welcoming...
  • lots of things that look like junk but are great learning aids
  • A DT room is another world.The smell, noise, machines, work space & atmosphere are completely different to any other classroom in the...school
  • A changing place learners want to be
(@misstreeteacher, @cdtMrHay, @mrcharlwood, @andrewhirstdt)
And finally one room had carpets - which strikes me as a luxury!
Many thanks to all of you who took the time to tweet to me – I’ll be putting together a blog post about your ideal D&T room soon.
Contributions from:
@mrcharlwood, @andrewhirstdt, @fitzpatrickjim, @patlink72, @tristramshepard, @CDTMrHAy, @DTteacher1001, @maghullhighDT, @cranny44, @misstreeteacher, @nohandsup
If i've missed you off - let me know and I'll add your name to the list.